Bookkeeper vs accountant: who does what, what each costs, and when you need both
A bookkeeper records and reconciles your transactions every month. An accountant, often a CPA or an enrolled agent, uses those books to prepare your tax return, plan your taxes and, if a lender asks, review or audit your statements. You need both when the year has a return to file and months of transactions behind it, which describes most small businesses. You need only one when the job in front of you clearly belongs to one side.
The quickest way to work out which is to list the jobs, not the job titles.
Which jobs belong to which?
| Job in front of you | Who does it | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Categorizing last month's bank and card transactions | Bookkeeper | Routine monthly recording; paying accountant rates for it is the usual overpay |
| Matching each account to its statement | Bookkeeper | Monthly reconciliation is the core of the job |
| Recording payroll from the provider's report | Bookkeeper | The accountant reviews the year's totals |
| Year-end depreciation and accrual entries | Accountant, sometimes the bookkeeper | Often posted by the bookkeeper from the accountant's schedule |
| Filing the income tax return | Accountant or credentialed preparer | Bookkeepers don't file |
| Sizing quarterly estimated tax | Accountant | Needs current books to work from |
| Answering an IRS letter | CPA, enrolled agent or attorney | That is representation |
| Reviewed or audited statements for a bank | CPA firm | Only a licensed CPA firm can issue them |
Anyone can call themselves a bookkeeper or an accountant. A CPA license can be checked on NASBA's CPAverify search or your state board's site, and enrolled agents appear in the IRS directory of preparers with credentials.
What does each cost?
The Bureau of Labor Statistics' May 2025 medians are $24.36 an hour for bookkeeping clerks and $40.23 for accountants and auditors, or $50,670 and $83,680 a year. Those are employee wages. A firm bills more, because its rate covers its overhead, but the gap between the two roles holds.
The bigger cost question is where the hours fall. Bookkeeping hours come every month. Accountant hours come in a few weeks around year end. Pay accountant rates for monthly hours and the bill climbs fast.
Four ways to cover one bakery's year
Copperleaf Bakery is fictional: one location, two employees, one bank account, one card. The fees below are assumptions so the arithmetic is clear, not quotes from anyone.
| Setup | Monthly work | Year-end work | Year total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Accountant does everything | 6 hours a month at an assumed $150 an hour: 10,800 | Return: 1,500 | 12,300 |
| Bookkeeping service plus accountant | Assumed $300 a month: 3,600 | Return 1,500 and a planning call 400: 1,900 | 5,500 |
| Owner keeps the books in software, accountant at year end | Software at $79 a month: 948, plus the owner's own 60 hours | 1,900 | 2,848 plus 60 hours |
| Nobody until March | None | Catch-up at an assumed 20 hours × $150: 3,000, then the return: 1,500 | 4,500 |
The last row looks cheaper than the bookkeeping service until you price what it buys. Copperleaf gets one set of books a year, built in a hurry in March. For eleven months the owner has no profit and loss, no idea whether the second employee was affordable, and nothing to size estimated tax payments from. The catch-up is also the most expensive way to get bookkeeping done, because it's bookkeeping billed at accountant rates.
The third row is the cheapest in dollars, and it suits an owner who likes the work. The 60 hours are real, though. Price your own hour honestly before you choose it.
When do you need both?
Most years. The bookkeeper keeps the months right, and the accountant files from them. Signs you need the accountant more than once a year:
- Your first employee
- A profit jump with no estimated payments made
- A lender asking for reviewed or audited statements
- A letter from the IRS or the state
- Sales into several states, or inventory for the first time
- Talk of an S corporation election, a partner or a second company
And signs you need the bookkeeper sooner rather than later: you can't say what last month's profit was, your card payments are sitting in an expense category, you're more than two months behind, or your accountant's last invoice had a line for cleanup.
The full side-by-side, with the credentials explained and a fictional grooming shop's year priced with both, is in our guide to bookkeeper vs accountant.
Disclosure: I'm Damin and I run ZeraBooks, so weigh this part accordingly. ZeraBooks is not a CPA firm and doesn't prepare or file tax returns. Our bookkeeping service does the monthly column: you upload statements, bills and invoices through a portal, our team records and reconciles every account, and you see the work in a read-only login. At year end your accountant gets the trial balance, profit and loss, balance sheet and cash flow as a PDF, with the full ledger as a CSV. The service starts at $150 a month (USD), with the exact price set after a free call. If you'd rather keep the books yourself, the ZeraBooks software is $79 a month billed annually. More on our bookkeeping services page.
Write down the job you need done this month. It usually tells you who to call.
Comments
Post a Comment